Peanut Butter S’More Cookies

I want to start by saying thank you for all the prayers and well wishes that you were all so kind to leave for me last week.

I wish I had good news to share, but the doctor still has not called with the biopsy results. If I don’t hear back later today I may have to give up my whole not drinking Starbuck’s for Lent thing so I can heavily caffeinate myself!

All kidding aside, I’m hanging in there. I’m still a little wigged out by the whole thing, but there’s nothing to do but wait. I’m still trying to have an attitude of gratitude, but some moments that’s harder to do than others…

In the meantime, in an effort to distract myself, I made cookies. Lots and lots of cookies.

These cookies in fact…

I have a bit of an obsession with s’mores. Pretty much s’more anything.

I’d like to blame it on Girl Scouts. Once upon a time, I got roped into being a Girl Scout Leader. And the girls all nicknamed me S’more. Don’t ask me why – there’s really not a good reason.

It was only naturally that we looked for any and all excuses to eat s’mores. After all they’re kind of like a Girl Scout rite of passage.

I had no idea how much fun it would be to be a Girl Scout leader or how much I would come to love “my girls.”

My troop full of the sweetest and giggly girls on the planet!

These cookies are a great reminder of all the silly songs and laughs we had together!

Peanut Butter S’More Cookies
Yields: About 3 dozen

½ c. shortening
¾ c. creamy peanut butter
⅓ c. granulated sugar
⅓ c. light brown sugar
1 egg
2 tbs. milk
1 tsp. vanilla
1 c. all purpose flour
½ c. graham cracker crumbs
1 tsp. baking soda
½ tsp. salt
1 c. mini marshmallows
4 – 1.55 oz. Hershey bars, broken into chunks

Preheat oven to 375 degrees F.

In a large mixing bowl, beat shortening, peanut butter, granulated sugar and brown sugar until light and fluffy. Add egg, milk, and vanilla; beat well. Mix in flour, graham cracker crumbs, baking soda, and salt until well combined, but do not over mix.

Shape dough into 1” balls. Place on ungreased cookies sheets. Flatten slightly with the palm of your hand or the bottom of a glass.

Bake 6 minutes or until slightly set. Remove from the oven and add three mini marshmallows and three small chunks of Hershey Bar to each cookie. Return to the oven 3-4 more minutes until lightly browned.

Cool 1-2 minutes and then remove to wire racks and cool completely before storing in an airtight container.

Have a wonderful Monday!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. 1

    I hope all goes well and keep us posted! The cookie recipe sounds fantastic…and your photos are perfect! Thinking of you….

  2. 3

    Isn’t being a Girl Scout leader the best?! I’m my daughter’s troop leader and we have a blast. Can’t wait for warmer weather so we can go camping! Speaking of perfect camping food, I’m dying over these cookies! They look amazing and so gooey. I can’t wait to try them out! :)

    • 4

      It truly is! There were times it drove me crazy, but they were so sweet and so much fun. I wouldn’t trade all the craziness for even a moment of it!

  3. 5

    Can order dozen of those cookies?:)) They look divine Jen!
    Beautiful photos, and looks like you have fun group around you! I am keeping my fingers crossed that everything is alright!!

  4. 7

    These look amazing! Suddenly, my bowl of cereal for breakfast doesn’t look so appetizing. Ha! Thanks for sharing this great recipe and your droolworthy photos, Jen.

  5. 9

    My fingers are crossed for you to hear good news soon. You must be going crazy, you poor thing!

    Those cookies are perfect. I am thinking you spent a lot of time placing all of those pieces of chocolate and marshmallows in the right spots. They look wonderful!

    • 10

      I was so slap happy it wasn’t funny Kristen! I’m so lazy and impatient that sometimes I wonder if I’ll make it as a pastry chef!

  6. 11

    I have been wanting to try s’mores cookies for ages. But you beat me to the idea of using a peanut butt cookie base. Love!

  7. 12

    These cookies are a great distraction. I would be baking up a storm if I were you. I saw this first on Facebook and couldn’t wait to see it on a real life computer screen. They look fantastic. And that girl scout circle is so cute. I wish I could join again.

  8. 14

    I remember s’mores from Girls Scouts, too. I just wish they sold door to door around here still.

    • 15

      We got them door to door, but they don’t seem to be as good as they used to be. The cookies were smaller, drier, and harder than I ever remember them being. They’re sitting in the pantry largely untouched!

  9. 16

    This is been something I’ve been wanting to try for a while. Delicious!! I know that waiting for medical results can drive a person insane! It’s tough. Hang in there. Hoping for the best news for you!

  10. 18

    I love regular s’more cookies… but peanut butter is even better!

  11. 19

    I was thinking about you over the weekend. I completely support your Starbucks idea. There are some days I don’t think I’d make it without my afternoon java. I would love to have one of these babies with my coffee today! I hope you get good words from your doc soon.

  12. 21

    Yum! These would definitely make my Monday MUCH better! They look sooo smore-riffic! :) I’m glad you’re hanging in there, it’s crazy how they make you wait after getting you all shook up! Have some dark chocolate, that way you can get some caffeine and indugle in a delicious treat. :)

  13. 22

    Oh good lord, I am drooling! I’m obsessed with s’mores too, and the only thing better than s’mores is s’mores AND peanut butter. I am dying for one of these babies!

  14. 23

    Hey Jen…. I am still keeping you in my prayers. I hope you get good news soon. :) The waiting game is the total pits! I’m glad you found these wonderful cookies to keep you busy. They look beyond beautiful. Those chunks of chocolate and partially melted marshmallow… unbelievably good!! I loved the girl scout pictures… so cute. :)

    • 24

      Thanks Ramona! It’s really starting to drive me crazy. I should know this afternoon when they take the stitches out. Fingers crossed!

  15. 25

    Girl!!! The first day of my hard core back on track eating healthy, and you make these!! Hoping you hear news quickly!

  16. 27

    I cannot resist a marshmallow, in any form. Just AMAZING!

  17. 28

    These just look amazing! They are the best Smores-anything I’ve ever seen! I love how the chocolate and marshmallows are so bold and chunky-that’s some great texture! I bet those girls really enjoyed them! I wish I was a girl scout, maybe I’ll join :)

  18. 29

    These sound amazing! I love that you have combined two classics, a PB cookie and a Smore…something I want to taste!!!

  19. 30

    I missed your news, but you can count on my prayers! I am sorry about the insurance situation, too…ugh! Fingers crossed it will all work out. And thanks for sharing these amazing cookies…you have the best ideas!!!

  20. 32

    I missed your news too (blame a crazy past few days) but am sending up prayers for patience and good news. In the meantime, Starbucks and these cookies would definitely distract me! Adding Reese Cups to s’mores is one of my favorite parts of camping. PS: I definitely go to Starbucks when I’m stressed too. I love knowing that others do the same :)

  21. 34

    Oh, that must be so frustrating to be kept waiting! I know you must be feeling anxious, but hang in there!

    Um, peanut butter and s’mores in one cookie?! I’m in love!

  22. 35

    Oh no, I didn’t know you need a biopsy! I am thinking of you and hoping for good news soon. These cookies are such a great treat, I hope you take some time to enjoy a few yourself.

  23. 37

    Love the picture with your scouts! :)
    These would be my wife’s undoing, but since I don’t like marshmallows, they’re probably not for me. Looks like they would be a huge hit with the girls!

  24. 39

    These are the cookies to end all cookies. I’ll take a dozen, please! :)

  25. 40
  26. 41

    Where have these cookies been all my life?! Beautiful photos by the way.

    I hope some good news is coming your way. I’ve been thinking about you!

  27. 43

    Jen…these cookies are gorgeous…..and I think I could use a plate of these myself lately! I love how the chocolates and marshmallows sit on top and are not all smooshed in! I didn’t know you were a girl scout leader. I think that is so awesome and your giggly girls are so adorable! Keeping you close in my thoughts!

  28. 45

    I bake to distract myself too. Good luck with everything.
    PS – these cookies look fantastic!

  29. 47

    Do you chill the batter before cooking ?

Please leave some comment love!